Well, I tried. I tried the whole ‘use the iPad Pro instead of my computer for a week’ thing and barely lasted a day. It doesn’t fit my workflow like my MacBook Air does, so I stopped trying to force it – and that’s OK. Apple’s newest largest tablet doesn’t need to be a laptop replacement to be good, but for a $300 premium over the cheapest iPad Air 2, it does need to deliver more than just a larger screen.
In some ways it does. Thanks to a faster processor and more RAM, the iPad Pro can enable a new class of applications that feel as powerful as desktop apps. Support for the Apple Pencil is limited to this iPad, so if your work includes drawing or drafting, or you’d rather handwrite notes than type them, your choice is clear: buy this iPad Pro or wait a year to see if Pencil support trickles down to more models.
So much screen, you could drive a truck between those icons.
But if you aren’t planning to use the Pencil, it could be hard for most people to justify the extra cost over an iPad Air 2 or even an iPad mini 4 – at least, it is for me. As a work tool, the iPad Pro is a little like the Mac Pro, or the MacBook Pro, or even something specialised like a mitre saw: if you really need it to do your job, you likely know you need it, and you don’t need me to tell you. If you find yourself wondering if you really need it… you probably don’t.
The Pencil is the iPad Pro’s big selling point
Using the Pencil is awesome. It feels natural, and it writes naturally, and makes a cheap rubber-tipped capacative stylus feel like trying to write your name with a hot dog. Drawing and even just doodling with it are wonderful experiences thanks to the pressure sensitivity and tilt detection that help it act more or less as you would expect, with very little lag. I haven’t done much drawing or painting since college, but the Pencil just makes me want to use it, and the fact that I can doodle, colour, sketch or mind-map while catching up on a show in Hulu in a Picture-in-Picture window appeals to me in a unique way. It’s a strange blend of nostalgia for the time when paper and pencils were my daily tools of choice, and that futuristic tingle of using something that feels so cutting edge.
iPad Pro with pencil
The Pencil has next to no learning curve, since it reacts to your movements pretty much like a real pencil would.
I’m not really sure why it’s so round – I hate putting it down and seeing it roll away – and I’m fairly afraid of losing the little cap that covers the Lightning port. And I don’t actually need the Pencil for my workflow, since I mostly type text into boxes and edit JPEGs in Pixelmator. So while I love using it like I used to use notebooks and pens, I could buy an iPad mini and a lot of very fancy notebooks and pens before I hit the $900 barrier to entry of the iPad Pro and Pencil. But graphic designers will think this setup plus an app like Astropad is a bargain compared to a Wacom Cintiq. More uses for the Pencil could emerge over time as well – developers and tinkerers are already experimenting.
Hits and misses when trying to work
Some work apps really do benefit from a bigger canvas. Drawing apps like the wonderful Procreate, sure. Editing photos with Pixelmator, definitely. Apps with a lot of tools like iMovie are a natural for a larger screen. And when you’re working with two apps side by side, it’s great to be able to give each of them the space of an entire iPad Air. But the apps I use the most on my iPad – Byword, Safari, Kindle, Mail – are just as good on a 9.7in iPad Air (or even a 7.9in iPad mini) as they are on the 12.9in iPad Pro.
Plus, running two apps side by side isn’t exactly multi-tasking. I kept running into limitations that I could work around, but didn’t want to have to. I liked having Byword open along with Safari in Split View on the iPad Pro. But on my Mac, I typically have more than one Byword document open at a time – one file with notes and another with an article in progress, usually – and the iPad can’t do that, since you can’t have the same app open in both sides of Split View. If you want to see two webpages side by side rather than just in tabs, you have to open them in different browsers. And, of course, not every iPad app supports Split View.
That’s not all. On my Mac, I use a few utilities that can run in the background, like RescueTime, which logs every minute I spend using various Mac apps and websites, but has no iOS version. Only on my Mac can I record Skype calls for the podcast, while plugged into ethernet for the occasion. My Mac lets me download files more easily and organise them however I like – although the iCloud Drive app in iOS 9 has made that easier on the iPad than it’s been in the past.
It’s still the best iPad ever
One of the things I like best about the iPad Pro is that while it isn’t as capable a work machine as my Mac, it’s a way better iPad than my Mac. No, really – for all the iOS creep into Mac (from iBooks to Maps to Launchpad to swipe gestures), the iPad is still better at a slew of tasks that my brain has firmly categorised as ‘mobile’ since iOS does them so well.
As I set up my iPad Pro, I first took a look at the Applications folder on my Mac, so I could grab equivalent iOS App Store offerings like Slack, Byword, Pixelmator, Tweetbot and Things. But then I took a look at my iPhone home screens, so I’d remember to grab my favourites from the mobile side, such as Kindle, My Fitness Pal, Spotify and Pocket Casts. It was cool to be able to log a snack or take a quick Instapaper break, and then get back to my writing and editing work, without having to switch devices. And I loved listening to podcasts or music while writing full-screen, then just swiping up to Control Center for the playback buttons, always handy but tucked neatly out of sight.
Still, everything in the paragraph above is just as possible on the smaller iPads than the nice, big, roomy iPad Pro. Apps on the Pro launch faster, which makes Split View feel more fluid, since you’re switching apps and flipping back and forth in a blink. But aside from Pencil support and overall speed, I’m hard-pressed to name a task I can do better on the iPad Pro than on the smaller (and more reasonably priced) iPads in the lineup.
It’s light in my bag, but big on my lap
Big as it is, the iPad Pro feels a lot lighter in my shoulder bag than the 13in MacBook Air I typically carry. Even with the Smart Keyboard, which bulks the iPad Pro up to 2.3 pounds, it’s a noticeable change from my 1043g (2.9-pound), 13in MacBook Air. When working at a table, the iPad Pro doesn’t feel too large, but when I curl up in bed to watch Netflix or read Kindle books on it, it starts to feel a little unwieldy – I want to prop it up on pillows way on the other side of the bed, or I feel like I’m watching movies too close to the screen.
The speakers are much improved, though, which does make a difference when using the iPad Pro as an entertainment device. Apple included four speakers, and the top two are used for treble while the bottom two are used for bass – no matter how you hold the tablet. They sound good, loud enough to fill an average room with music even if you don’t have a Bluetooth speaker handy.
Still, compared to using a laptop, the iPad Pro is just less comfortable all around. When sitting at a desk with the Smart Keyboard, I didn’t like how I couldn’t adjust the angle of the screen, or keep my hands in one relative position. (Reaching up to tap the screen feels awkward at first, but after about a day and a half, I found myself reaching up to tap the screen of my MacBook Air, instead of going for the trackpad.) The software keyboard keeps coming up even when I have a Bluetooth keyboard paired, thanks to a bug that I’m told is being addressed in iOS 9.2 – it’s not a deal-breaker now, but it is annoying for half the screen to be gobbled up by a keyboard I don’t need.
Battery life is excellent – starting a workday at 85 percent charged, I didn’t get the 10 percent warning until almost 4pm. I do wish the iPad had the Low Power Mode that I’ve been enjoying so much in iOS 9 for my iPhone, but that mode works by throttling some performance behind the scenes (stopping background app refresh, slowing down the processor speed), and Apple may have felt these weren’t acceptable trade-offs to eke more power out of the iPad Pro. The tablet ships with a 12-watt USB power adapter for charging – both the battery life and the tiny universal charger are big points for the iPad Pro over a MacBook.
Apple offers multiple sizes of iPhones, laptops, and iPods, so it makes total sense to expand the iPad lineup from two sizes to three, and with the Pencil, Apple’s given the 12.9in iPad a rightful claim on the name Pro.
For me, it’s just not worth the considerable premium in price over an iPad Air 2 (which starts at $699 for 16GB) or my favourite model, the iPad mini 4 ($569). The Pencil is fabulous, but instead of shelling out $1249 for the entry-level (32GB, Wi-Fi only) iPad Pro and another $165 for the Pencil, I could get a maxed out 128GB iPad mini 4 with cellular for $989 and have plenty of money left for all the fancy pens and notebooks my heart desires.