First look: Kindle Fire HD (vs iPad)

Mark Hattersley
10 September, 2012
View more articles fromthe author
AAA

Kindle Fire HD (vs iPad)

Amazon, www.amazon.com.au

Pros 

Cheap; faster innards may make a better experience; easy access to Amazon store content

Cons 

Not as versatile as iPad or Google Nexus 7

TBC

Reviews

Amazon has fired a shot at Apple’s with two new Kindle products: the Kindle Fire and Kindle Fire HD set to launch in Australia in October. This first-look review pits what we know of both Kindle products against Apple’s current iPad offering, along with how they will fare against a cheaper, smaller, iPad mini that Apple is rumoured to be announcing in October.

Both the new Kindle Fire and Kindle Fire HD are substantially cheaper than the current iPad, and indeed cheaper than both the Google Nexus 7 and any expected Apple iPad mini offering. The entry level Kindle Fire costs just £129 ($199) with the Kindle Fire HD starting at £159 ($245) in the UK, however Australian pricing is yet to be confirmed.

The Kindle Fire HD comes in a 16GB model or a larger 32GB model. If it does arrive in Australia at $245, in terms of price it will fare well against the current iPad (which starts at $429 for the 16GB iPad 2). It even fares well against Google’s bargain-bin Nexus 7, $249 which is for a smaller 8GB model, and $299 for a 16GB model.

So in terms of price it’s clear that Amazon is being extremely aggressive here. Whether that translates into a quality experience is something that we will discover when the Kindle Fire and Kindle Fire launch in Australia in October.

We weren’t that enamoured with the performance of the original Kindle Fire, which we felt had a sluggish interface, which was fine for reading books and watching movies, but clumsy for anything you did in between.

The new Kindle Fire has a new 1.2GHz processor and 1GB of RAM which Android claims offers 40% faster performance than the original Kindle Fire. There may be something in this: Google’s Nexus 7 sports a 1.3GHz processor and the interface for that feels far smoother than earlier Android tablets, even though Android isn’t as slick as iOS, now that it’s not so sluggish it feels in the same ballpark. So it may be that Amazon has addressed a key fault with the original Kindle Fire.

Both the Kindle Fire and Kindle Fire HD sport 7in displays, rather than the 9.7in screen found on the current iPad range.

With a resolution of 1280 x 800 announced on the Kindle Fire HD the device offers 254 PPI (pixels per inch) putting it in the same category as the Retina display new iPad (and considerably better than the 132 PPI of the iPad 2). Of course, pixel density isn’t everything and we doubt the display on the Kindle Fire comes close to matching the IPS display that has always been standard on the iPad, but it’s certainly something to consider.

What’s really important about the Kindle Fire is the way that it is completely focussed on delivering content. Books and movies, mainly, but also music and Android games. This is obviously a double-edged sword as you buy into an Amazon ecosystem with a Kindle Fire, but as ecosystems go it’s not a bad. Kindle bookstore is great, Amazon owns Lovefilm, and Amazon’s general store hardly lacks popularity. Having all these services rolled into a device that’s sold at a reduced rate isn’t exactly a bad proposition.

On the other hand Amazon is, however, pushing you towards purchasing content from them. And that content isn’t quite as good in Australia as it is in the US.

We don’t really know what Apps you’ll be able to install on the Kindle Fire. Even though the device is based upon Android, you can only install apps on it thorough the Amazon Android Appstore (which has its own Android app store). There’s no mention yet of any other Apps that might source content in Australia. We imagine Amazon is going to restrict access to services that rival its own offerings, although time will tell. You can, apparently, side-load Android apps by going into Settings and choosing “Allow install from unknown source” but we’d still like to know what’s available to the general public via the usual store.

What we are also missing in Australia is the coolest new Amazon product of them all, the Kindle Fire HD 8.9in 4G/LTE. This has a faster 1.8GHz processor, 1GB RAM and a FullHD+ IPS display with a resolution of 1920 x 1200 (254 PPI). In the US it comes in 32GB and 64GB options and starts at US$299, a good US$100 less than the iPad 2 and US$200 less than the new iPad with which it shares its Retina-like display. Competitive? Just a bit.

It may well be that Amazon is skipping Australia and Europe for this launch as it did with the original Kindle Fire because it wants to focus on getting its products into US consumers hands. Or it may be that Amazon knows that it’s not really going to win this war on features, but price. And it needs to drive the price down as far as possible to reach its target audience.

But Amazon can play the price-war game more comfortably than either Apple or Google. More than any other company Amazon has tied up content with delivery; it pretty much owns the electronic book market globally. Amazon is on track to have 50% of the electronic book market by the end of the year, and it has revealed that Kindle editions are outselling its physical hardcover equivalents by a 3-to-1 margin.

“Last year there were more than two dozen Android tablets launched into the marketplace and nobody bought them,” Jeff Bezos, Amazon CEO said. “People don’t want gadgets anymore. They want services. Kindle Fire is a service. It greets you by name, it comes out of the box with your content preloaded, it makes recommendations for you.”

How the Amazon Fire is going to fare against the iPad, and to a lesser extent Google’s Nexus 7 is debatable. In terms of versatility it doesn’t come close to an iPad with the App Store, mind you, if it arrives at $199 for the Fire or $245 for the Fire HD it is a compelling alternative to those on a budget. That could change if Apple launches an iPad mini for around $300, which we hope would be a 7in iPad with hopefully a Retina display.

It’s probably an easier device for people to understand and use than the Nexus 7, although it doesn’t have the same versatility. Having said that, we’re not sure if a 7in tablet needs the versatility of an iPad, maybe just delivering books, movies, TV shows, and basic web services (email, web browsing, Twitter, Facebook, and so on) is enough.

Macworld Australia‘s buying advice

What it does do is encourage customers into buying digital and real-world products from Amazon, hence the lower price. Many people are happy to shop at the Kindle store, and it’s still not a bad service overall. If the Kindle Fire has a half decent interface thanks to its new faster processor it’ll have a lot of happy customers.

 

One Comment

One person was compelled to have their say. We encourage you to do the same..

  1. Peter T. says:

    Apparently the Kindle Fire has advertisements, which cannot be removed or disabled. That makes likely to be quite unsuitable for schools, an area where Google could have made some in-roads.

Leave a Comment

Please keep your comments friendly on the topic.

Contact us