Ridiculous outrage over rumour Apple will ditch headphone jack

Macworld Australia Staff
12 January, 2016
View more articles fromthe author
AAA
News

Here’s how things work in today’s world. There’s a rumour or some newly announced feature in a piece of technology. That potential new feature or function has the potential to make your existing piece of technology seem dated or, worse still, obsolete.

So, in your hastily generated anger, you create an online petition, share it with a bunch of your friends and hope they share it with their friends. Hopefully, within a day or two, it will reach the inboxes of thousands of people who, in a moment of “me too outrage” sign the petition.

It sounds silly but this is what has happened over the last week or so as rumours that Apple will be dropping the 3.5mm headphone jack on the next iPhone are heating up.

Here’s the situation. As Macworld Australia reported back in November, there’s a rumour doing the rounds that Apple is planning to ditch the 3.5mm headphone jack that has been the way we’ve connected our headphones to portable audio devices since the days of the portable transistor radio.

The “plan” – remember, this is all rumour and conjecture at this point – is to replace the 3.5mm socket with Lightning-connected or wireless headphones.

In some ways, this makes a lot of sense. It’s one less port on the device so, in theory, on less thing that can go wrong. It’s also one less port to waterproof if Apple adds some water resistance to the iPhone. Lightning is a digital connection so, in theory, we should be able to get much better audio quality as the 3.5mm port is analogue only.

But the downside – that draw filled with old headphones suddenly gets a little less useful. I have a few sets of cheap headphones in case my kids or their friends forget to bring headphones. If I recall, they were freely given away at a hotel I stayed in so patrons could use them with gym equipment, such as treadmills and exercise bikes, that was equipped with TV screens.

And this is where the “Internet outrage” starts. A petition at Sum of Us submits that “Apple is about to rip off every one of its customers. Again”.

As far as I can tell, there’s nothing in any Apple documentation that states the need to buy a new iPhone every time a new model is released. Sure, it’s nice to have the latest and greatest Cupertino has to offer but it’s not mandatory.

The petitioner says Apple will “singlehandedly create mountains of electronic waste – that likely won’t get recycled” and cites the example of Apple replacing the old 30-pin iPod connector as an example of Apple’s irresponsible behaviour.

That example is a stretch as the old connector was fragile and could only be inserted one way. Anyone arguing the Lightning connector is inferior is probably not looking at all the facts. And the old adaptor was in plat for a decade so it was hardly a rushed change.

Of course, change is rarely easy. And anyone who has followed Apple over the last three decades will know they rarely hold back on what they perceive to be innovation because of legacy technology. Floppy drives, CD/DVD drives ADB, FireWire 400 and 800 (with different connectors) – all have fallen victim to Apple’s march forward.

Even common implementations of USB are for the chopping block if the MacBook, with its single USB-C connector, is a sign of the times.

At no point does Apple put a gun to anyone’s head and force them to upgrade.

Amazingly, the petition has managed to get over 240,000 people to sign on the virtual line – with few than 10,000 more signatures needed before the petitioner reaches his or her target of 250,000. Why that number is important is a mystery but in the world of Internet outrage it’s probably as good a target as any.

It’s easy to get angry about things. And in our world there’s a lot to get emotional about. War, famine, mistreatment… all of these are great causes that need our passion.

But to get this much attention for something that hasn’t happened, may not happen and, ultimately, matters little given there’s no mandatory requirement smacks of petulance and reactive outrage.

Will Apple dropping the 3.5mm jack be an inconvenience to me, if they do it and I buy a new iPhone? Of course it will. I have three sets of headphones I use regularly, two of which are wired. But I’m already carrying an adaptor with me so I can use them on planes where airlines still have those silly two-pronged connectors. So, another small adaptor isn’t really a big deal – and certainly not enough to make me dump my rather expensive noise-cancelling headphones.

What do you think? Have I got it wrong? Is the petitioner right and I’m off with the fairies?

Let me know your thoughts in the comments section.

 

14 Comments

14 people were compelled to have their say. We encourage you to do the same..

  1. Sacha says:

    Good article. It’s just a rumor after all. :)

  2. Scott says:

    You’re wrong. All change is bad. This is just the beginning. Soon there will be no connectors at all on phones and then what will we do? I personally do not intend buying a new phone until Apple bring out an iPhone with a floppy disc drive. Where do I sign this petition?

  3. Stewart says:

    What Scott said! I’m outraged that there’s no punch card programming on my iPhone!

  4. Jamie says:

    I heard a rumour that there was a rumour that there was some potential discussion about Apple maybe producing a car as well….

    Or perhaps that was just idle gossip :-D

  5. Stephen says:

    Great Idea!! all those damned cables getting tangled up with my seat belt, sunglasses, handbrake, as well as arm movement, what a relief if there is no headphone cable running from the iPhone, just a wi-fi connection to small ear-buds. And no, I am not listening to music, I use my iPhone as my GPS using Maps. Out damn Spot! Begone you relic of the C20th.

  6. Craig says:

    I hardly ever use the head phone jack, think in over 2 years with my 5s I’ve used the supplied head phones like twice.

    Tech moves on and next thing you know (if this is more than a rumor) they will be praising Apple for the high quality digital audio from their new iPhone 7.

  7. Steph says:

    I heard from a mate, who heard from a buddy of his, who spoke to his gardener who knows Tim Cook’s garbologist that apple is making a two wheeled self propelled vehicle known as Apple Bike…

  8. Brett says:

    I wouldn’t sign such a petition but seriously though, I’ve got probably $800-900 of headphone I use with my Apple gear and I’m not about to toss them. Most of these will long outlast and iDevice. My iPhones are gaspingly slow by the time I toss them but my Sennheiser noise cancelling and Grado Labs open backed headphones will last for years longer. If it does happen I’m assuming that I’ll be able to get a Lightning to 3.5mm adapter.
    And forget somebody saying that the digital signal from Lightning is superior to 3.5mm analogue. Of course it is but that improvement is vastly limited by lower quality headphones and more importantly the listening environment. There’s no point having a great digital signal if the environment isn’t conducive to enjoying the benefit.

  9. Peter MacProf Geelong says:

    Needless change is a bloody nuisance. I like built-in DVD slots and the like as I had an Apple Superdrive for my Macbook Air and a fraying cable made it useless. I use my Macs as tools for writing, making movies, storing and editing photos, writing, etc and I don’t need to upgrade just for the sake of having something newer. When a new MacBook came out without the DVD slot, I went out and bought the just-superseded one so I could retain all of my most-liked features.
    Memo to MacWorld staff: The in-out slidey box thing is a drawer; draw is something you do with a pencil. YES, I KNOW IT PASSED THE SPELL-CHECKER!

  10. Peter MacProf Geelong says:

    Why did my comment disappear when I clicked the SUBMIT button?

  11. Macworld Australia Staff says:

    All comments are moderated before publication.

  12. Javier azcoitia says:

    If you think to use an adaptor for the lightning connector it should have an analog to digital audio converter; not a very simple and not an economy answer

  13. David C says:

    I work in music technology/audiovisual/studio roles in tertiary education, and work every day with digital audio. The great value of a 3.5mm stereo headphone jack is that you can ALWAYS get a sound from your device and there are millions of things that you can then plug it into. A ubiquitous connection like this can be adapted in so many ways, and its simplicity is a lifesaver in so many situations. Digital connections change design every few years, require hardware/software compatibility to be functional, and so inevitably leave behind a trail of obsolescence. I do hope Apple keeps the headphone jack. And by the way, just because a connector is digital doesn’t simply “in theory” make it better quality than analog!

  14. Tom3 says:

    So if apple do this, they will be just copying the oppo r5 the thinest phone in the world. They customers complained over that one so oppo dont make their phones without headphone jacks now. So apple is just going to copy what oppo did, funny that.

Leave a Comment

Please keep your comments friendly on the topic.

Contact us